Explore Haunted Ohio: Click on a county below to find your local Ohio ghost stories!

Perry County Ohio Ghosts and Hauntings - Bloody Horseshoe Grave


 

Bloody Horseshoe Grave

Methodist Church Cemetery
Rushville, OH 43150

A grave in Otterbein Cemetery offers an everlasting ghostly reminder to all who take romance and tradition too lightly . . . The Legend: A gravestone has an impression of a bloody horseshoe because a man refused to return a wedding gift horse to his late wife's parents after she died.

 

 

Bloody Horse Shoe Grave - Rushville, Ohio

The Cemetery - Bloody Horse Shoe Grave - Rushville, Ohio